Table 1

Summary of published studies including a qualitative synthesis

SourceCountryMen/women, nAge, yearsBMI, kg/m2Diabetes history, yearsFollow-up periodAnalysis
Bae et al (2018)23Korea5/10Mean 62.9 (SD 4.3)Mean 24.8 (SD 3.5)Mean 13.8 (SD 6.7)180 minITT
Imai et al (2010)24Japan7/8Mean 61.7 (SD 11.6)Mean 24.7 (SD 4.3)Mean 5.3 (SD 8.8)120 minITT
Imai et al (2011)25Japan48/53Mean 63.4 (SD 11.7)Mean 23.4 (SD 4.1)Mean 7.3 (SD 8.3)2 yearsITT
Imai et al (2012)*26Japan
(Total 17)
Mean 65.7 (SD 9.6)72 hours (3 days)ITT
Imai et al (2013)27Japan6/13Mean 65.5 (SD 9.4)Mean 22.5 (SD 3.1)Mean 16.4 (SD 10.2)72 hours (3 days)ITT
Imai et al (2014)*28Japan
(Total 13)
Mean 69.1 (SD 6.7)ITT
Kuwata et al (2016)*22Japan9/3Mean 59.7 (SD 9.7)Mean 25.3 (SD 4.1)Mean 3.6 (SD 5.5)240 minITT
Shukla et al (2017)29USA7/9Mean 57.7 (SD 7.6)Mean 32.8 (SD 3.3)Mean 3.8 (SD 2.4)180 minITT
Shukla et al (2018)*30USA7/9Mean 57.7 (SD 7.6)Mean 32.8 (SD 3.3)Mean 3.8 (SD 2.4)180 minITT
Shukla et al (2019)31USA4/11Mean 52.4 (SD 3.4)Mean 34.2 (SD 1.1)NA180 minITT
Trico et al (2016)32Italy13/7Mean 64.5 (SD 21.4)Mean 30.6 (SD 3.5)Less than 58 weeksPP
Yabe et al (2019)33Japan
(Total 29)
Mean 49.5 (SD 5.9)Mean 25.9 (SD 2.1)NA22–26 weeks (6 months)PP
  • *Studies included in the qualitative synthesis.

  • BMI, body mass index; ITT, intention-to-treat; PP, per-protocol.