Table 1

Characteristics of the included studies

Study author and yearTrial registration detailsType of designParticipants (n)Age categoryC-L control algorithm24 hours or overnightComparatorStudy duration (weeks)
Thabit et al, 201512NCT01961622Crossover33AdultMPC24 hoursSAP12
Thabit et al, 201512NCT01778348Crossover25ChildrenMPCOvernightSAP12
Kropff et al, 201515NCT02153190Crossover32AdultMPCOvernightSAP8
Tauschmann et al, 201813NCT02523131ParallelC-L (46), control (40)BothMPC24 hoursSAP12
Benhamou et al, 201921NCT02987556Crossover63AdultDiabeloop24 hoursSAP or PLGS12
Brown et al, 201918NCT03563313ParallelC-L (112), control (56)BothControl-IQ24 hoursSAP26
Brown et al, 202019NCT03591354ParallelC-L (54), control (55)BothControl-IQ24 hoursPLGS13
Breton et al, 202020NCT03844789ParallelC-L (78), control (23)ChildrenControl-IQ24 hoursSAP16
Kovatchev et al, 202017NCT02985866ParallelC-L (78), control (23)BothControl-IQ24 hoursSAP13
Kovatchev et al, 202016NCT02679287Crossover80AdultInControlOvernightSAP8
McAuley et al, 202014ACTRN12617000520336ParallelC-L (61), control (59)BothPID24 hoursMDI or insulin pump26
  • C-L, closed loop; MDI, multiple daily injections; MPC, model predictive control; PID, proportional, integral, differential algorithm; PLGS, predictive low-glucose suspend; SAP, sensor-augmented pump.