Summary
Twenty-six Type 1 diabetic patients previously treated for 10–20 months with twice daily conventional bovine isophane insulin (containing at least 1000 ppm proinsulin) were changed to highly purified (<1 ppm proinsulin) bovine isophane for 6 months (Switch group). Insulin antibody levels fell significantly from a geometric mean of 14.9 to 9.1 μg/l. Thirty-two patients with newly diagnosed Type 1 diabetes were treated with the same highly purified bovine isophane insulin twice daily for 6 months (Starter group). Their insulin antibody levels rose from a geometric mean of 1.9 to 8.2 μg/l in contrast to values of 1.4 rising to 16.3 μg/l in an age and sex matched historical control group treated from diagnosis only with twice daily conventional bovine isophane insulin. Lipoatrophy at injection sites developed in three (9%) in the Starter group treated with highly purified bovine isophane compared to 7 (22%) of those on conventional bovine isophane. Insulin dose and diabetic control did not differ between the groups. Starterand Switch groups were subsequently treated with semi-synthetic human isophane insulin for 6 months during which insulin antibody levels fell significantly from a geometric mean of 8.5 to 4.4 μg/l (p<0.001). We conclude that bovine insulin purified to less than 1 ppm proinsulin is significantly less immunogenic than its conventional proinsulin contaminated counterpart but even at this level of purity is still more immunogenic than human insulin of equivalent purity.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Reeves WG (1980) Immunology of diabetes and insulin therapy. In: Thompson RA (ed) Recent advances in clinical immunology. Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh, pp 183–220
Walford S, Allison SP, Reeves WG (1982) The effect of insulin antibodies on insulin dose and diabetic control. Diabetologia 22: 106–110
Kurtz AB, Mathews JA, Mustaffa BE, Daggett PR, Nabarro JDN (1980) Decrease of antibodies to insulin, proinsulin and contaminating hormones after changing treatment from conventional beef to purified pork insulin. Diabetologia 18: 147–150
Reeves WG (1981) Antibody production during insulin therapy — patterns of response and clinical sequels. In: Keck K and Erb P (eds) Basic and clinical Aspects of immunity to insulin. Walter De Gruyter, Berlin, pp 219–235
Reeves WG, Douglas CA (1982) C-peptide antibodies induced by bovine insulin therapy. Clin Exp Immunol 50: 171–177
Reeves WG, Kelly U (1982) Insulin antibodies induced by bovine insulin therapy. Clin Exp Immunol 50: 163–170
Peacock I, Taylor A, Tattersall RB, Douglas CA, Reeves WG (1983) Effects of new insulins of insulin and C-peptide antibodies, insulin dose and diabetic control. Lancet 1: 149–152
Wilson RM, van der Minne P, Deverill I, Heller SR, Gelsthorpe K, Reeves WG, Tattersall RB (1985) Insulin dependence: problems with the classification of 100 consecutive patients. Diabetic Med 2: 167–172
Reeves WG, Barr D, Douglas CA, Gelsthorpe K, Hanning I, Skene A, Wells L, Wilson RM, Tattersall RB (1984) Factors governing the human immune response to injected insulin. Diabetologia 26: 266–271
Menard L, Dempsey ME, Blankstein LA, Aleyassine H, Wacks M, Soeldner JS (1980) Quantitative determination of glycosylated haemoglobin AI by agar gel electrophoresis. Clin Chem 26: 1598–1602
Peacock I (1984) Glycosylated haemoglobin: measurement and clinical use. J Clin Pathol 37: 841–851
Heding LG, Larsson Y, Ludvigsson J (1980) The immunogenicity of insulin preparations. Antibody levels before and after transfer to highly purified porcine insulin. Diabetologia 19: 511–515
Holman RR, Steemson J, Darling P, Reeves WG, Turner RC (1984) Human ultralente insulin. Br Med J 228: 665–669
Blundell TL, Cutfield JF, Cutfield SM, Dodson EJ, Dodson GG, Hodgkin DC, Mercola DA (1972) Three-dimensional atomic structure of insulin and its relationship to activity. Diabetes 21: (Suppl 2) 492–505
Reeves WG (1985) Immunological aspects of therapy. In: KGMM Alberti & LP Krall (eds) The Diabetes Annual. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 67–81
Reeves WG, Allen BR, Tattersall RB (1980) Insulin-induced lipoatrophy: evidence for an immune pathogenesis. Br Med J 280: 1500–1503
Evans-Jones LG (1982) Lipoatrophy in a patient on highly purified beef insulin. Arch Dis Child 57: 638–639
Jones GR, Statham B, Owens DR, Jones MK, Hayes TM (1981) Lipoatrophy and monocomponent porcine insulin. Br Med J 282: 190
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Wilson, R.M., Douglas, C.A., Tattersall, R.B. et al. Immunogenicity of highly purified bovine insulin: a comparison with conventional bovine and highly purified human insulins. Diabetologia 28, 667–670 (1985). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00291973
Received:
Revised:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00291973