Abstract
We derive a two-stage model in which health plans first compete to be selected by employers and subsequently compete to be chosen by employees. We identify the key determinants of competition and show that increasing competition at one stage often comes at the expense of competition at the other stage. Many economists and policymakers have argued that in order to increase competition among health plans, employers should offer multiple plans and structure premium contributions to make employees more price sensitive. While our theoretical model shows that following this policy prescription may not actually lead to lower premiums, our empirical analysis provides some support for this recommendation. We also find that if employers instead pay the full premium, premiums increase when they offer additional plans. These results have important implications for both employers and policymakers.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bradford, D. W. (1996). “Efficiency in Employment-Based Health Insurance: The Potential for Supra-Marginal Cost Pricing, ” Economic Inquiry 34 (April), 341-356.
Brooks, J. M., A. Dor and H. Wong. (1997). “Hospital-Insurer Bargaining: An Empirical Investigation of Appendectomy Pricing. ” Journal of Health Economics 16 (4), 417-434.
Bundorf, M. K. (2001). “Employee Demand for Health Insurance and Employer Health Benefit Choices. ” Working Paper, Stanford University.
Cutler, D. M. and S. Reber. (1996). “Paying for Health Insurance: The Tradeoff Between Competition and Adverse Selection. ” Working Paper No. 5796, NBER.
Cutler, D. and R. Zeckhauser. (1998). “Adverse Selection in Health Insurance. ” In A. Garber (ed.), Frontiers in Health Policy and Research (Vol. 1). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research.
Dowd, B. E. and R. Feldman. (1998). “Employer Premium Contributions and Health Insurance Costs. ” In Michael A. Morrisey (ed.), Managed Care and Changing Health Care Markets. Washington, D.C.: AEI Press.
Dowd, B. E. and R. Feldman. (1994 /1995). “Premium Elasticities of Health Plan Choice. ” Inquiry 31 (4), 438-444.
Dowd, B. E., R. Feldman and J. Klein. (1987). “What Do Employers Really Want in a Health Plan?” Business and Health 4 (3), 44-48.
Dranove, D., K. E. Spier and L. Baker. (2000). “Competition Among Employers Offering Health Insurance. ” Journal of Health Economics 19 (1), 121-140.
Encinosa, W. and T. Selden. (2001). “Designing Employer Health Benefits for Heterogeneous Workforces: Risk Adjustment and Its Alternatives. ” Inquiry 38 (3), forthcoming.
Enthoven, A. C. and R. Kronick. (1989). “A Consumer Choice Health Plan for the 1990s: Universal Health Insurance is a System Designed to Promote Quality and Economy. ” New England Journal of Medicine 320 (1), 29-37; (2), 94-101.
Enthoven, A. C. (1990). “Multiple Choice Health Insurance: The Lessons and Challenge to Employers. ” Inquiry 27, 368-375.
Enthoven, A. C. (1989). Theory and Practice of Managed Care Competition in Health Care Finance. Amsterdam, New York, Oxford, Tokyo: North Holland.
Enthoven, A. C. (1988). “Managed Competition: An Agenda for Action. ” Health Affairs 7 (3), 25-47.
Feldman, R., B. Dowd and M. Maciejewski. (2001). “A Demand-Side View of Risk Adjustment. ” Inquiry 38 (3), forthcoming
Harvey, P. and B. Schone. (1994). “More or Less Choice: Health Insurance Options of U.S. Workers. ” Working Paper, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.
Hunt, K. A., S. J. Singer, J. Gabel, D. Liston and A. C. Enthoven. (1997). “Paying More than Twice: When Employers Subsidize Higher-Cost Health Plans. ” Health Affairs 16(6), 150-156.
Jensen, G., R. Feldman and B. Dowd. (1984). “Corporate Benefit Policies and Health Insurance Costs. ” Journal of Health Economics 3, 275-296.
Jensen, G., M. Morrisey and J. Marcus. (1987). “Cost Sharing and the Changing Pattern of Employer-Sponsored Health Benefits. ” The Milbank Quarterly 65 (4), 521-550.
Jones, S. B. (1990). “Multiple Choice Health Insurance: The Lessons and Challenge to Private Insurers. ” Inquiry 27 (2), 161-166.
Levy, H. (1998). “Who Pays for Health Insurance? Employee Contributions to Health Insurance Premiums. ” Working Paper, University of California at Berkeley.
Schone, B. S. and P. F. Cooper. (2001). “Assessing the Impact of Health Plan Choice. ” Health Affairs 20 (1), 267-275.
Selden, T. (1999). “Premium Subsidies for Health Insurance: Excessive Coverage vs. Adverse Selection. ” Journal of Health Economics 18, 709-725.
U.S. Congressional Research Service. (1988). Costs and Effects of Extending Health Insurance Coverage. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Vistnes, G. (1997). “Strategic Alliances in Multi-Firm Systems. ” Working Paper, Antitrust Division, U.S. Depart-ment of Justice.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vistnes, J.P., Cooper, P.F. & Vistnes, G.S. Employer Contribution Methods and Health Insurance Premiums: Does Managed Competition Work?. International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics 1, 159–187 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1012878628161
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1012878628161