Summary
In the past 10 years the techniques of gel filtration and ion exchange chromatography have made available insulins of markedly enhanced purity. These highly purified insulins have made immunological insulin resistance a rarity, and result in absent or clinically insignificant levels of insulin antibodies in insulin-treated diabetics. Insulin allergy has not been reported with highly purified insulins alone, and is rare even when the patient has previously received recrystallised insulin. Generalised allergic reactions to insulin and insulin resistance are associated with the enhanced immunological reaction to intermittent insulin therapy. The use of highly purified insulins for short courses of treatment is therefore mandatory, particularly in patients with infections. Injection-site lipoatrophy, a relatively common occurrence with the older insulins, disappears on changing to highly purified preparations.
Following a change to highly purified insulins, insulin dose requirements will fall gradually with insulin antibody levels. When switching from conventional beef to highly purified pork insulins, a more immediate change in dose requirements may occur so that prospective reductions in insulin dose are indicated.
It is still uncertain whether moderate levels of insulin antibodies are associated with any difference in metabolic control. This is partly a reflection of difficulties in measuring diabetic control, and partly a lack of properly designed studies. Current insulins of both older and newer Types give plasma insulin profiles that are far from physiological Insulin antibodies cross the placenta and may contribute to increased fetal insulin secretion and neonatal hypoglycaemia. Pre-pregnant patients should be changed to the newer preparations. Highly purified insulins cost little more than conventional insulins in the free market, and should be used in all newly diagnosed insulin-requiring diabetics.
More recently, human insulin has become available through both DNA recombinant technology and amino acid substitution techniques. It has proved to have identical characteristics to pork insulin both in vitro and in normal subjects. Clinical trials with human insulin are at present in progress.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ahmed, M.; Gannon, M.C. and Nuttall, F.Q.: Postprandial plasma glucose, insulin, glucagon and triglyceride responses to a standard diet in normal subjects. Diabetologia 12: 61–67 (1976).
Alberti, K.G.M.M. and Nattrass, M.: Highly purified insulins. Diabetologia 15: 77–80 (1978).
Andersen, O.O. and Egeberg, J.: The clinical significance of insulin antibodies. Acta Paediatrica Scandinavica 270 (Suppl.): 63–68 (1977).
Andreani, D.; Javicoli, M.; Tamburrano, G. and Menzinger, G.: Comparative trials with monocomponent (MC) and mono-species (MS) pork insulin in the treatment of diabetes mellitus. Influence on antibody levels, on insulin requirements and on some complications. Hormone and Metabolic Research 6: 447–454 (1974).
Asplin, C.M.; Hartog, M. and Goldie, D.J.: Change of insulin dosage, circulating free and bound insulin and insulin antibodies on transferring diabetics from conventional to highly purified porcine insulin. Diabetologia 14: 99–105 (1978).
Berson, S.A. and Yalow, R.S.: Quantitative aspects of the reaction between insulin and insulin-binding antibody. Journal of Clinical Investigation 38: 1996–2016 (1959).
Berson, S.A. and Yalow, R.S.: Insulin in blood and insulin antibodies. American Journal of Medicine 40: 676–690 (1966).
Berson, S.A.; Yalow, R.S.; Bauman, A.; Rothschild, M.A. and Newerly, Y.: Insulin I131 metabolism in human subjects. Demonstration of insulin binding globulin in circulation of insulin treated subjects. Journal of Clinical Investigation 35: 170–190 (1956).
Binder, C.: Absorption of injected insulin. Acta Pharmacologia Toxicologia 27(Suppl. 2): 1–87 (1969).
Bloom, S.R.; Barnes, A.J.; Adrian, T.E. and Polak, J.M.: Autoimmunity in diabetics induced by hormonal contaminants of insulin. Lancet 1: 14–17 (1979).
Bloom, S.R.; West, A.M.; Polak, J.M.; Barnes, A.J. and Adrian, T.E.: Hormonal contaminants of insulin; in Bloom (Ed.) Gut Hormones, pp.318–322 (Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh, London, New York 1978).
Bollinger, R.E.; Morris, J.H.; McKnight, F.G and Diederich, D.A.: Disappearance of 131I labelled insulin from plasma as a guide to management of diabetes. New England Journal of Medicine 270: 767–770 (1964).
Bottermann, P.; Gyaram, H.; Wahl, K.; Ermler, R. and Lebender, A.: Pharmacokinetics of biosynthetic human insulin and characteristics of its effect. Diabetes 4: 168–169 (1981).
Bruni, B.; Bruni, K.B.; Gamba, S.; Giolitti, A.; Rittatore, R. and Turco, G.L.: Long-term clinical trial with porcine monocomponent Lente insulin (Monotard®). Panminerva Medica 19: 247–254 (1977).
Bruni, B.; Gamba, S.; Regis, G. and Turco, G.L.: Proinsulin and α-component antibodies in diabetics after long-term mono-component insulin treatment. Diabetologia 14: 165–169 (1978).
Chance, R.E.; Kroeff, E.P.; Hoffman, J.A. and Frank, B.H.: Chemical, physical and biologic properties of biosynthetic human insulin. Diabetes Care 4: 147–154 (1981).
Chance, R.E.; Root, M.A. and Galloway J.A.: The immunogenicity of insulin preparations. Acta Endocrinologica 83(Suppl. 205): 185–198 (1976).
Christy, M.; Deckert, T. and Nerup, J.: Immunity and autoimmunity in diabetes mellitus. Clinics in Endocrinology and Metabolism 6: 305–332 (1977).
Crome, P. and Keen, H.: Partial lipodystrophy and insulin-resistant diabetes. Diabetes et Metabolisme 4: 81–84 (1978).
Davidson, J.K. and De Bra, D.W.: Immunologic insulin resistance. Diabetes 27: 307–318 (1978).
Deckert, T.; Andersen, O.O.; Grundahl, E. and Kerp, L.: Isoimmunization of man by recrystallized human insulin. Diabetologica 8: 358–361 (1972).
Deckert, T.; Andersen, O.O. and Poulsen, J.E.: The clinical significance of highly purified pig insulin preparations. Diabetologia 10: 703–708 (1974).
De Meyts, P.; Halban, P. and Hepp, K.D.: In vitro studies on biosynthetic human insulin: An overview. Diabetes Care 4: 144–146 (1981).
Dixon, K.; Exon, P.D. and Malins, J.M.: Insulin antibodies and the control of diabetes. Quarterly Journal of Medicine 176: 543–553 (1975).
Dolovich, J.; Schnatz, J.D.; Reisman, R.E.; Yage, Y. and Arbesman, C.E.: Insulin allergy and insulin resistance. Journal of Allergy 46: 127–137 (1970).
Federlin, K.; Laube, H. and Velcovsky, H.G.: Biologic and immunologic in vivo and in vitro studies with biosynthetic human insulin. Diabetes Care 4: 170–174 (1981).
Foiling, I.: Insulin-anti-insulin complexes. Acta Endocrinologica 83(Suppl. 205): 199–209 (1976).
Gale, E.A.M.; Kurtz, A.B. and Tattersall, R.B.: In search of the Somogyi effect. Lancet 2: 279–282 (1980).
Galloway, J.A.: Insulin treatment for the early 80s: facts and questions about old and new insulins and their usage. Diabetes Care 3: 615–622 (1980).
Galloway, J.A. and Bressler, R.: Insulin treatment in diabetics. Medical Clinic of North America 62: 663–680 (1978).
Galloway, J.A.; Spradlin, C.T.; Root, M.A. and Fineberg, S.E.: The plasma glucose response of normal fasting subjects to neutral regular and NPH biosynthetic human and purified pork insulins. Diabetes Care 4: 183–188 (1981).
Gattner, H.G.; Donho, W. and Naithani, V.K.: Enzyme-catalysed semi-synthesis with insulin derivatives; in Brandenburg and Wollmer (Eds) Insulin Chemistry, Structure and Function of Insulin and Related Hormones. Proceedings of the Second International Insulin Symposium, Aachen, September 1979, pp.117–123 (Walter de Gryter, Berlin 1979).
Gerlis, L.S.; Adeniyi-Jones, R.; Jones, R.H.; Barnes, G.D. and Sönksen, P.H.: Porcine and semi-synthetic human insulins: a comparison of their metabolism in man. Diabetologia 21: 274 (1981).
Gill, G.V.; Home, P.D.; Massi-Benedetti, M.; Pernet, A.; Copaldo, B.; Husband, D.J.; Burrin, J.M.; Johnston, D.G. and Alberti, K.G.M.M.: Clinical and metabolic characteristics of patients with ‘brittle’ diabetes. Diabetologia 21: 507 (1981).
Goeddel, D.V.; Kleid, D.G.; Bolivar, F.; Heyneker, H.L.; Yansura, D.G.; Crea, A.; Hirose, T.; Kraszewsli, A.; Itakura, K. and Riggs, A.D.: Expression in E. coli of chemically synthesized genes for human insulin. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 76: 106–110 (1979).
Goldman, J.; Baldwin, D.; Rubenstein, A.H.; Klink, D.D.; Blackard, W.G.; Fisher, L.K.; Roe, T.F. and Schnure, J.J.: Characterization of circulating insulin and proinsulin-binding antibodies in autoimmune hypoglycemia. Journal of Clinical Investigation 63: 1050–1059 (1979).
Goldstein, H.H.: Allergy and diabetes; in Marble et al. (Eds.) Joslin’s Diabetes Mellitus, pp.701–707 (Lea and Febiger, Philadelphia 1971).
Hagedorn, H.C.; Jensen, B.N.; Krarup, N.B. and Wodstrup, I.: Protamine insulinate. Journal of the American Medical Association 106: 177–180 (1936).
Hallas-Møller, K.; Jersild, M.; Peterson, K. and Schlichtkrull, J.: Zinc insulin preparations for single daily injection. Journal of the American Medical Association 150: 1667–1671 (1952).
Harfenist, E.J. and Craig, L.C.: Counter current distribution studies with insulin. Journal of the American Chemical Society 74: 3083–3087 (1952).
Heding, L.G.; Persson, B. and Strongenberg, M.: B-cell function in newborn infants of diabetic mothers. Diabetologia 19: 427–432 (1980).
Home, P.D. and Alberti, K.G.M.M.: Human Insulin. Clinics in Endocrinology and Metabolism 11: 453–483 (1982).
Home, P.D.; Pickup, J.C.; Keen, H.; Alberti, K.G.M.M.; Parsons, J.A. and Binder, C.: Continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion: comparison of plasma insulin profiles after infusion or bolus injection of the mealtime dose. Metabolism 30: 439–442 (1981).
Home, P.D.; Massi-Benedetti, M.; Shepherd, G.A.A.; Hanning, I.; Alberti, K.G.M.M. and Owens, D.R.: A comparison of the activity and disposal of semi-synthetic human insulin and porcine insulin in normal man by the glucose clamp technique. Diabetologia 22: 41–45 (1982).
Irvine, W.J.; Al-Khateeb, S.F.; DiMario, U.; Feek, C.M.; Gray, R.S.; Edmond, B. and Duncan, C.J.: Soluble immune complexes in the sera of newly diagnosed insulin dependent diabetics and in treated diabetics. Clinical and Experimental Immunology 30: 16–21 (1977).
Irvine, W.J.; DiMario, U.; Feek, C.M.; Ting, A.; Morris, P.J.; Gray, R.S. and Duncan, L.J.P.: Insulin antibodies in relation to islet cell antibodies and HLA antigens in insulin-dependent (Type I) diabetes. Journal of Laboratory and Clinical Immunology 1: 111 (1978).
Jones, G.R.; Statham, B.; Owens, D.R.; Jones, M.K. and Hayes, T.M.: Lipoatrophy and monocomponent porcine insulin. British Medical Journal 282: 190 (1981).
Jorpes, J.E.: Recrystallized insulin for diabetic patients with insulin allergy. Archives of Internal Medicine 83: 363–371 (1949).
Keen, H.; Glynne, A.; Pickup, J.C.; Viberti, G.C.; Bilous, R.W.; Jarrett, R.J. and Marsden, R.: Human insulin produced by recombinant DNA technology: safety and hypoglycaemic potency in healthy man. Lancet 2: 398–401 (1980).
Kodama, S.; Kasuga, M.; Seki, A.; Ninomiya, M.; Sakwrai, T.; Mosishita, Y.; Matsuo, M. and Matsuo, T.: Congenital generalized lipodystrophy with insulin-resistant diabetes. European Journal of Paediatrics 127: 111–119 (1978).
Koenig, R.J.; Peterson, C.M.; Jones, R.L.; Saudek, C.; Lehrman, M. and Cerami, A.: Correlation of glucose regulation and haemoglobin A1c in diabetes mellitus. New England Journal of Medicine 295: 417–420 (1976).
Korp, W. and Levett, R.E.: Erfahrungen mit Monokomponenten-Insulin. Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift 85: 326–330 (1973).
Kumar, D.; Miller, L.V. and Mehtalia, S.D.: Use of dexamethasone in treatment of insulin lipoatrophy. Diabetes 26: 296–299 (1977).
Kurtz, A.B. and Nabarro, J.D.N.: Circulating insulin binding antibodies. Diabetologia 19: 329–334 (1980).
Kurtz, A.B.; Matthews, J.A.; Mustaffa, B.E.; Doggett, P.R. and Nabarro, J.D.N.: Decrease of antibodies to insulin, proinsulin and contaminating hormones after changing treatment from conventional beef to purified pork insulin. Diabetologia 18: 147–150 (1980).
Lavaux, J.P.; Ooms, H.A. and Christiansen, A.H.: Insulin antibodies in insulin-treated patients; a clinical trial with highly purified insulins. Excerpta Medica International Congress Series 316: 40–46 (1973).
Leslie, D.: Generalised allergic reaction to monocomponent insulin. British Medical Journal 2: 736–737 (1977).
Lithner, F.: Treatment of diabetes mellitus with monocomponent insulins. A preliminary report. Opuscula Medica 20: 249–254 (1975).
Logie, A.W. and Stowers, J.M.: Hazards of monocomponent insulin. British Medical Journal 1: 879–880 (1976).
Lougheed, W.D.; Woulfe-Flanagan, H.; Clement, J.R. and Albisser, A.M.: Insulin aggregation in artificial delivery systems. Diabetologia 19: 1–9 (1980).
Lowell, F.C.: Immunologic studies in insulin resistance: II. The presence of a neutralizing factor in the blood exhibiting some characteristics of an antibody. Journal of Clinical Investigation 23: 233–240 (1944).
Ludvigsson, J. and Heding, L.G.: C-peptide in children with juvenile diabetes. Diabetologia 12: 627–630 (1976).
Malherbe, C.; deGasparo, M.; de Hertogh, R. and Hoet, J.J.: Circadian variations of blood sugar and plasma insulin levels in man. Diabetologia 5: 397–404 (1969).
Märki, F. and Albrecht, W.: Biological activity of synthetic human insulin. Diabetologia 13: 293–295 (1977).
Markussen, J.; Jorgensen, K.; Thim, L.; Damgaard, U.; Sørensen, E.; Dodson, G. and Chawdhury, F.: Human monocomponent insulin: chemistry and characteristics of human insulin (Novo). Diabetologia 21: 302 (1981).
Massi-Benedetti, M.; Burrin, J.M.; Capaldo, B. and Alberti, K.G.M.M.: A comparative study of the activity of biosynthetic human insulin and pork insulin using the glucose clamp technique in normal subjects. Diabetes Care 4: 163–167 (1981).
Miller, W.L. and Baxter, J.D.: Recombinant DNA — a new source of insulin. Diabetologia 18: 431–436 (1980).
Mirsky, I.A. and Kawamura, K.: Heterogeneity of crystalline insulin. Endocrinology 78: 1115–1119 (1966).
Morihara, K.; Oka, T. and Tsuzuki, H.: Semi-synthesis of human insulin by trypsin-catalysed replacement of Ala-B30 by Thr in porcine insulin. Nature 280: 412–413 (1979).
Mustaffa, B.E.; Daggett, P.R. and Nabarro, J.D.N.: Insulin binding capacity in patients changed from conventional to highly purified insulins. An indication of likely response. Diabetologia 13: 311–315 (1977).
Nakagawa, S.; Suda, N.; Kudo, M. and Kawasaki, M.: A new Type of hypoglycaemia in a newborn infant. Diabetologia 9: 367–375 (1973).
National Diabetes Advisory Board: A study of insulin supply and demand. US Department of Health, Education and Welfare (NIH), 78-1588 (1978).
Nicol, D.S.H. and Smith, L.F.: Amino-acid sequence of human insulin. Nature 187: 483–485 (1960).
Oakley, N.W.: Effect of ‘fractional’ insulins on total plasma insulin binding capacity and insulin requirement in severe diabetes. Lancet 1: 994–996 (1976).
Owens, D.R.; Jones, M.K.; Hayes, T.M.; Heding, L.G.; Alberti, K.G.M.M.; Home, P.D.; Burrin, J.M. and Newcombe, R.G.: Human insulin: study of safety and efficacy in man. British Medical Journal 282: 1264–1266 (1981).
Phelps, R.L.; Freinkel, N.; Rubenstein, A.H.; Kuzuya, H.; Metzger, B.E.; Boehm, J.J. and Mølsted-Pedersen, L.: Carbohydrate metabolism in pregnancy. XV. Plasma C-peptide during intravenous glucose tolerance in neonates from normal and insulin-treated diabetic mothers. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 46: 61–68 (1978).
Pickup, J.C.; Home, P.D.; Bilous, R.W.; Keen, H. and Alberti, K.G.M.M.: Management of severely brittle diabetes by continuous subcutaneous and intramuscular insulin infusions: evidence for a defect in subcutaneous insulin absorption. British Medical Journal 282: 347–350 (1981).
Pickup, J.C. and Keen, H.: Continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion: a developing tool in diabetes research. Diabetologia 18: 1–4 (1980).
Pickup, J.C.; Keen, H.; Viberti, G.C.; White, M.C.; Kohner, E.M.; Parsons, J.A. and Alberti, K.G.M.M.: Continuous subcutaneous insulin infusion in the treatment of diabetes mellitus. Diabetes Care 3: 290–300 (1980).
Pirro de, R.; Fusco, A.; Spallone, L.; Mignatta, R. and Lauro, R.: Insulin antibodies prevent insulin receptor interaction. Diabetologia 19: 118–122 (1981).
Raptis, S.; Karaiskos, C.; Enzmann, F.; Hatzidakis, D.; Zoupas, C.; Souvatzoglou, A.; Diamantopoulos, E. and Moulopoulos, S.: Biologic activities of biosynthetic human insulin in healthy volunteers and insulin-dependent diabetic patients monitored by the artificial endocrine pancreas. Diabetes Care 4: 140–143 (1981).
Reeves, W.G.: Immunology of diabetes and insulin therapy; in Thompson (Ed.) Recent Advances in Clinical Immunology, No. 2, pp. 182–200 (Churchill Livingstone Inc., Edinburgh 1980).
Reeves, W.G. and Dodson, G.G.: Binding specificity of human insulin antibodies. Diabetologia 21: 319 (1981).
Reeves, W.G.; Allen, B.R. and Tattersall, R.B.: Insulin induced lipoatrophy: evidence for an immune pathogenesis. British Medical Journal 280: 1500–1503 (1980).
Root, M.A.; Chance, R.E. and Galloway, J.A.: Immunogenicity of insulin. Diabetes 21(Suppl. 2): 657–660 (1972).
Root, M.A.; Spradlin, C.T.; Galloway, J.A. and Chance, R.E.: Factors affecting the measurement of insulin in the blood of human subjects following the administration of purified pork and human insulin. Diabetologia 21: 321 (1981).
Roy, B.; Chou, M.C.Y, and Field, J.B.: Time-action characteristics of regular and NPH insulin in insulin-treated diabetics. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 50: 475 (1980).
Schernthaner, G.; Borkenstein, M.; Mathä, R.; Mayr, W.R. and Schober, E.: Analysis of insulin antibodies following human or pork MC insulin therapy in HLA-DR Typed juvenile diabetics: a prospective study. Diabetologia 21: 324 (1981).
Schlichtkrull, J.: Antigenicity of monocomponent insulins. Lancet 2: 1260–1261 (1974).
Schlichtkrull, J.; Bronge, J.; Ege, H.; Hallund, O.; Heding, L.G.; Jørgensen, K.; Markussen, J.; Stahnke, J.; Sundby, F. and Volund, A.: Proinsulin and related peptides. Diabetologia 6: 80–81 (1970).
Scott, D.A. and Fisher, A.M.: Studies on insulin with protamine. Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics 58: 78–92 (1936).
Sieber, P.; Kamber, B.; Holtmann, A.; Jöhl, A.; Riniker, B. and Rittel, W.: Total Synthese von Humaninsulin Gezielter Bildung der Disulfidbindungen. Helvetica Chimica Acta 57: 2617–2621 (1974).
Spellacy, W.N. and Goetz, F.C.: Insulin antibodies in pregnancy. Lancet 2: 222–224 (1963).
Starzynska, R.; Seniow, S.; Kodejszko, F.; Kowalski, H.; Starzynski, S. and Depowska, B.: Studies on the transport of insulin antibodies across the placenta to the fetus and their effect on the fetal pancreatic islet system. Acta Diabetologica Latina 6: 573–584 (1969).
Staub, A.; Sinn, L. and Behrens, O.K.: Purification and crystallization of hyperglycemic-glycogenolytic factor (HGF). Science 117: 628–629 (1953).
Steiner, D.F.; Hallund, O.; Rubenstein, A.; Cho, S. and Bayliss, C.: Isolation and properties of proinsulin, intermediate forms, and other minor components from crystalline bovine insulin. Diabetes 17: 725–736 (1968).
Stout, R.W.: Diabetes and atherosclerosis — the role of insulin. Diabetologia 16: 141–150 (1979).
Taylor, R.; Home, P.D. and Alberti, K.G.M.M.: Plasma free insulin profiles after administration of insulin by jet and conventional syringe injection. Diabetes Care 4: 377–379 (1981).
Teuscher, A.: The place of the ‘monocomponent’ insulins in the therapy of diabetes mellitus. Schweizerische Medizinische Wochenschrift 105: 485–494 (1975).
Teuscher, A.: Die biologische Wirkung von vollsynthetischem humanem Insulin bei Patienten mit Diabetes Mellitus. Schweizerische Medizinische Wochenschrift 109: 743–747 (1979).
Villa-Komaroff, L.; Efstratiodis, A.; Broome, S.; Lomedico, P.; Tizard, R.; Naber, S.P.; Chick, W.L. and Gilbert, W.: A bacterial clone synthesizing proinsulin. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (USA) 75: 3727–3731 (1978).
Villa-Komaroff, L.; Naber, S.P.; Broome, S.; Efstratiadis, A.; Lomedico, P.; Tizard, R.; Chick, W.L. and Gilbert, W.: Synthesis of proinsulin in bacteria; in Beers et al. (Eds) Polypeptide Hormones, pp.49–63 (Raven Press, New York 1980).
Wehner, H.; Huber, H. and Kronenberg, K.H.: The glomerular basement membrane of the rabbit kidney on long-term treatment with heterologous insulin preparations of different purity. Diabetologia 4: 255–263 (1973).
Winkle Van, M. and Levy, L.: Further studies on the reversibility of serum sickness cholesterol-induced atherosclerosis. Journal of Experimental Medicine 132: 858–867 (1970).
Witters, L.A.; Ohman, J.L.; Weir, G.C.; Raymond, L.W. and Lowell, F.C.: Insulin antibodies in the pathogenesis of insulin allergy and resistance. American Journal of Medicine 63: 703–709 (1977).
Wright, A.D.; Walsh, C.H.; Fitzgerald, M.G. and Malins, J.M.: Very pure porcine insulin in clinical practice. British Medical Journal 1: 25–27 (1979).
Yue, D.K. and Turtle, J.R.: Antigenicity of ‘monocomponent’ pork insulin in diabetic subjects. Diabetes 24: 625–632 (1975).
Yue, D.K. and Turtle, J.R.: New forms of insulin and their use in the treatment of diabetes. Diabetes 26: 341–345 (1977).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Home, P.D., Alberti, K.G.M.M. The New Insulins. Drugs 24, 401–413 (1982). https://doi.org/10.2165/00003495-198224050-00003
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2165/00003495-198224050-00003